Imagine three groups of people. You ask each group one question. How much would you pay to save migratory birds from drowning in uncovered oil ponds?
You tell the first group the nets will save 2,000 birds. You tell the second group 20,000. You tell the third group 200,000.
Logic says the third group should offer far more. They did not. The average offers were $80, $78 and $88.
A hundred times more bird yet almost the same gift.
William Desvousges and colleagues ran this study in the early 1990s. Daniel Kahneman made it famous in Thinking, Fast and Slow. It carries an awkward lesson for anyone who raises money. The size of the problem you describe may make almost no difference to what donors give.
One bird, not 200,000
Psychologists call this scope neglect. Our willingness to help barely changes as the scale of a problem grows.
Kahneman explains why. Our fast, intuitive thinking, which he calls System 1, handles numbers badly. It swaps the number for a single picture. In this case, one exhausted bird with its feathers soaked in oil.
That picture creates the emotion. The emotion sets the gift. And the picture stays the same whether you say 2,000 or 200,000. So the gift stays the same too.
Donors do not multiply. They feel, and then they give.
It gets worse as the numbers grow
The birds study is not a one-off. Three other findings point the same way.
One named person beats a statistic
Deborah Small, George Loewenstein and Paul Slovic asked people to give to Rokia, a seven-year-old girl in Mali. Others read statistics about millions facing hunger in Africa. Rokia raised more than twice as much. When the researchers added the statistics to Rokia’s story, gifts fell.
Compassion fades fast
Slovic and colleagues found that feelings and donations start to drop as soon as one child becomes two. He calls this psychic numbing. The more victims, the less we feel for each.
Numbers need a comparison
Christopher Hsee showed that people struggle to judge a figure on its own. Is 20,000 birds a lot? Most of us have no idea. Put 2,000 and 200,000 side by side and people do respond to scale. Show one number alone and they do not.
What this means for your next appeal
Most cases for support open with scale. “1 in 4 children.” “3.8 million people.” “Demand has risen 40%.” We assume a bigger number makes a stronger case. The evidence says it does not.
Five things to try instead.
- Lead with one. Open with one person, one animal, one place. Give them a name and a detail the reader can picture.
- Keep the big number away from the story. Statistics can weaken the emotional pull of an individual case. Put them later, or in a separate panel for the donors who want proof.
- Make the number concrete. “200,000 birds” is abstract. “£25 nets one pond” is a picture and a price.
- Give a comparison. If scale matters to your argument, show it against something. Last year against this year. Your city against the national average.
- Test it. Run the single story against the statistics-led version. Let your own donors tell you which works.
The takeaway
Your cause may help thousands. Your donor will give to one.
Scope neglect is not a flaw in your supporters. It is how every human brain works, including yours and mine. Good fundraising works with that, not against it.
Look at your current appeal. What is the first thing the reader sees? A number or a face?
Bernard Ross is a director of =mc consulting and leads its decision science practice. Find more on applying behavioural science to fundraising at contact him at bernardross@mc.consulting.